When the Phrase “Everything Happens for a Reason” Hurts There is a sentence people often say when something terrible happens: “Everything happens for a reason.” Sometimes those words are comforting. But sometimes they are deeply painful. Tell a parent who has lost a child that there is a reason. Tell someone who has survived violence that there is a reason. Tell someone whose life has been destroyed by war, betrayal, illness, or disaster: “Everything happens for a reason.” The person may ask: “What possible reason could justify this?” And that is where we need to slow down. Perhaps the phrase “everything happens for a reason” is too simple. Perhaps we need to distinguish between: meaning, cause, purpose, and justification . Something can have a cause without having a good purpose. Something can have consequences without being deserved. Something terrible can eventually produce something meaningful without the terrible event itself becoming good. That distinction is extremely important...